I have to say I actually sent these back, but only because I realized after I ordered them I had a fairly similar pair already that I had forgotten about because they had been put away for the summer and hadn't been worn in many months. I hated returning them because they were so cute and comfortable. I tried to exchange them for the leather version, but they didn't have the same width available in my size. I opted for exchanging them for a pair of Clarks. Unfortunately the Clarks were no comparison at all in comfort or fit. They had to be returned as well.
Since I loved the Mindy Trotters so much I decided to look again and try the option on the website that allows you to mark that you couldn't find your size and they will notify you if they come in. There turned out to be a M width available in my size (wanted a W width due to bunions - but decided to take a chance). So we'll see if I get lucky and they will fit ok.
Bottom line, LOVE this shoe. Styling is super cute. Comfort is amazing. Sizing seems to be spot on.