I originally ordered this shoe in the grey color in size 7.5 W. It fit beautifully, but was the wrong color grey so I sent it back. I liked it so much I ordered the same size in black. Imagine my surprise when I couldn't stuff my foot in the shoe! I ordered a second pair in 7.5 W and a pair in 8W in the hopes of finding a pair that fit like the grey color. The second 7.5W was also too small and the 8W was too long (but still felt narrow). Sadly, all variations of the shoe went back. It is a lovely shoe if you can find a pair to fit properly.